J. Dack posits “Scalzi’s Law.” Think of it as not unlike Godwin’s Law, only tastier.
THEY WERE A LIFETIME TOGETHER
- Home
- May 23, 2013
Whatever
Search Whatever
Archive (3/02 – now)
Administrivia
- About
- A Brief Biography of John Scalzi
- Availability for Interviews, Appearances and Writing Work
- Books by John Scalzi
- Contact Information
- Guidelines for Publicity, Blurbing, Unpublished Work, Retweets, Guest Blogging and Charitable Solicitations
- Scheduled Appearances
- Site Disclaimer and Comment Policy
- The Canonical Bacon Page
- The Scalzi Creative Sampler
The Big Idea
What's the Big Idea? Authors explaining the the big ideas behind their latest works, in their own words.
Authors: for information on how to participate, click here.
The Blatherations of Others
- boosette on Amazon’s Kindle Worlds: Instant Thoughts
- Greg on Amazon’s Kindle Worlds: Instant Thoughts
- na on Whatever Holiday Shopping Guide 2012, Day Two: Non-Traditionally Published Books
- Bryce Anderson on Amazon’s Kindle Worlds: Instant Thoughts
- Marcus Rowland on Amazon’s Kindle Worlds: Instant Thoughts
- retirement.preciousmetalsauthority1.com on Amazon’s Kindle Worlds: Instant Thoughts
- Teepee12 on Nebula Award Winners!
- Emily Marcus on The Sort of Crap I Don’t Get
- megpie71 on Amazon’s Kindle Worlds: Instant Thoughts
- mythago on Amazon’s Kindle Worlds: Instant Thoughts
- Christine Morgan on Amazon’s Kindle Worlds: Instant Thoughts
- Delphi Psmith on Amazon’s Kindle Worlds: Instant Thoughts
- taraoshea on Amazon’s Kindle Worlds: Instant Thoughts
- taraoshea on Amazon’s Kindle Worlds: Instant Thoughts
- karadin on Amazon’s Kindle Worlds: Instant Thoughts
Whatwitters
- The view from where I am. The word "bucolic" was invented for this. http://t.co/jNcM7ggMSA 16 hours ago
- Hello, Madison! 18 hours ago
- Madison area folks: I'll be at A Room Of One's Own, tomorrow at 4pm (note the time) for a reading and signing! Come! roomofonesown.com 18 hours ago
- RT @maureenjohnson: New game! Imagine things the new @amazon fanfic reader/editor might have to say or do! Tag: #amazonffeditor 19 hours ago
- RT @MykeCole: Well, the pocket program is out, so I guess it's safe to say: CONTROL POINT has won the 2013 Compton-Crook Award. See you all… 19 hours ago
- In Minneapolis airport. Only briefly. On my way to Madison. Sorry, Minnesota. It's not you, it's me. 19 hours ago
- RT @LadyDreamgirl: @scalzi Additionally the fedora is named after a female character played by Sarah Bernhardt, an amusing bit of irony 20 hours ago
- I've noted that the last time I wore a fedora the wind blew it off my head and under a bus, and I took that as a sign, re: me and fedoras. 20 hours ago
- I do feel sad fedoras are becoming shorthand for "socially-anxious woman-fearing dude" since it's a very fine type of hat. 20 hours ago
- I wonder if there's a correlation between dudes who use "misandry" in conversation and dudes wearing fedoras in their OKCupid profile pics. 20 hours ago
Recently on Whatever
- Madison! I’m at A Room Of One’s Own TOMORROW, 4pm! Note the Time!
- Amazon’s Kindle Worlds: Instant Thoughts
- The Big Idea: Rhiannon Held
- Gosh, We’re All Really Impressed Down Here I Can Tell You
- Portland! Brace Yourself, For I Shall Arrive! Tomorrow! 7pm! Powell’s in Beaverton!
- Seattle! Come See Me TODAY, 7pm, University Temple United Methodist Church!
- The Big Idea: Madeleine Robins
- Two SFWA Presidents
- Nebula Award Winners!
- A Mind Is a Terrible Thing to Taste
Random Whatever
Click this link -- and you'll be taken to a random Whatever entry in the archive. Which one will you get? Got me!
Proudly powered by WordPress · Theme: Minimum by StudioPress.
That law is 100% true.
Is this your version of a “Six Degrees” rule, John?
Probably true?
I thought Scalzi’s Law would be: “Any sufficiently delicious food is indistinguishable from bacon.”
It has the added bonus of being true.
Just bacon, or any edible porcine by-product?
at #5
Perhaps something like a “Pork Rind Corollary?”
Yeah, Godwin’s Law is not so much with the tasty. Kind of the opposite, really.
And the referent in Godwin’s law was a vegetarian! Which means that it touches on this new law not at all.
“I thought Scalzi’s Law would be: “Any sufficiently delicious food is indistinguishable from bacon.”
That’s Scalzi’s Second Law.
The Third Law could be: “Anything is funnier with bacon taped to it.”
If you’re going to have multiple Scalzi’s Laws, you have to formulate the Zeroeth Law — the underlying assumption without which the following laws are unnecessary.
For example, the Zeroeth Law for Newton’s Law is “There is such a thing as ‘mass.’” For Thermodynamics, it is “There is such a thing as ‘temperature.’”
For Scalzi’s Laws, the Zeroeth Law is obviously “There is such a thing as ‘bacon.”" Or for those purists who don’t mind a negative statement, “There is no such thing as ‘too much bacon.’”
Dr. Phil
@9
Consider this the official request for a photo of Scalzi with Bacon taped to himself.
I will throw in some cash towards the Athena College Fund if she manages to tape bacon to her dad and takes a picture without his knowledge.
With his clothes on, puh-leeze…..
How about a picture of John Scalzi rendered in bacon. Or if you are mor artistic a sculpture of John Scalzi made out of bacon.
I’m sick of all you baconazis and your belief in the mastermeat!
(Does that mean this thread is over or do I have to mention H-word? And by the H-word I mean “Hickory”)
#4: As tasty as bacon is, I am sure, to Scalzi, I suspect not even he would proclaim that all tasty foods taste the same. Bacon taste like chocolate? That’s heretical to those who love chocolate, and those who love bacon, and to those who love the taste of both, I suspect.
However, the law as he phrased it, I have no issue with, and agree it is probably true.
Also, I have heard those who love bacon say that not all porcine products have the same great taste.
Splitter!
No schisms in the dogma of bacon.
So what is the vegan equivalent of this law? I’m guessing “all food with tofu in it tastes almost but not entirely unlike meat.” But that’s just my experience after being cruelly tricked into trying “tasty” vegan products that included deep-fried tofu.
Not that I have a problem with veganism; just people trying to convince me that animal-free products taste like meat. That is not one of the advantages of a vegan life-style.
Though bacon-wrapped tofu tastes like bacon.
I’m a polyflavorist. Bacon and chocolate are both in my pantheon.
Bacon-wrapped tofu? I must try.
Also, Dr Phil, the Zeroth Law of Thermodynamics is definitely not what you think it is. It’s that two objects in thermal equilibrium with a third object are in thermal equilibrium with each other. In other words, if you let your bacon come to room temperature while sitting in a skillet, and you let your chocolate come to room temperature sitting in the same skillet, then the bacon won’t melt the chocolate since no energy flows.
Whereas, if you cook bacon, you can then cook pasta and toss in bacon and eggs, resulting in a delicious bacony spaghetti carbonara. The pasta cooks the eggs and keeps the bacon warm since the three are not in thermal equilibrium.
I so need to figure out how to work this into a lecture this semester…
Re: #15 & #18
Don’t forget the Bacon Chocolate. I’ve tried it. It is wonderful.
It’s been a tradition for me to easter-egg my work by putting a dalek someplace in every render (even if it’s replacing a bolt that ends up 2×2 pixels with Derek the Dalek).
From now on, John, in your honour Derek’s place will be taken by a strip of bacon. For your greater glory!
I’m still putting a fez on it, though. Some things are tradition
Why argue which is better, bacon or chocolate. Just have it all (and at the same time):
Bacon Ice Cream and Chocolate-Covered Bacon
http://www.aldenteblog.com/2008/07/the-bacon-duet.html
(and in keeping with the law, here’s another post that went from living wills to bacon)
http://jimvoorhies.com/index.php?p=414#comment-19946
Mark, I’m disappointed by your callous rejection of Dalekism in favor of this new fangled Orthodox Baconism.
kcarlile, remember Derek as I always shall:
http://www.imaginetix.co.uk/Images/hogjowl.jpg
agm:
I would love to have a Thermo class with a prof that used bacon to illustrate the basic principles. Its on the schedule for the fall. Since the book is “Chemical & Biomedical Applications of…”, I’m betting bacon will not be in it.
Also, I have to amend my corollary: “All vegan food with tofu in it tastes almost but not entirely like meat.”
Otherwise I would have obviously falsified it with my bacon-wrapped tofu example.
But what will the giraffophiles think?
It’s not chocolate but it is bacon candy!
http://voodoodoughnut.com/menu.html
Home of the bacon maple bar. There’s a photo, but it’s not listed in the text menu on the left which is more of a guideline than a menu really..
agm: And you’ve just defined what temperature means. “It’s that two objects in thermal equilibrium with a third object are in thermal equilibrium with each other. In other words, if you let your bacon come to room temperature while sitting in a skillet, and you let your chocolate come to room temperature sitting in the same skillet, then the bacon won’t melt the chocolate since no energy flows.” i.e., they are all at the same temperature. If such a condition could not occur, then there’d be no definition of temperature which would allow the regular enumerated laws of thermodynamics to stand as written. Hence my statement of the Zeroeth Law of Thermodynamics. (grin)
Dr. Phil
agm: The secret is not to work bacon into a lecture, it’s to work bacon into an exam. My first Physics exam this summer featured Iron Man, for example. (grin)
Dr. Phil
I will now blatantly blogwhore with a vaguely relevant post. It involves bacon, and has a passing reference it Schroedinger’s cat.
I thought Scalzi’s Law was “Nothing is so bad that it can’t be improved with bacon!”
I saw it and just had to direct you to it. A real bacon alarm clock. http://www.mathlete.com/portfolio/wakeNbacon.php
Dr Phil,
I have to disagree. Given that it has already happened once, your statement that one has to have the Zeroth Law to enumerate the other laws of thermodynamics just doesn’t make sense. Instead, it serves to complete the bridge between thermo and dynamics by adding critical theoretical structure, a bit analogous to how Maxwell’s work gave us electromagnetic wave propagation.
More usefully, a principle that says energy flows from bacon to chocolate because of a temperature difference cannot define the concept of temperature because of the way it relies on you having an independent definition of temperature, or else you’re begging the question. That’s where Professor Kelvin, his predecessors, and his contemporaries save the day.
http://www.thekitchn.com/thekitchn/good-questions/what-smells-do-you-like-waking-up-to-058757
Submitted too fast – meant to include:
This law is 100% true. I saw this today, and couldn’t think of anyone else. How does it feel to be forever connected with bacon?
http://www.thekitchn.com/thekitchn/good-questions/what-smells-do-you-like-waking-up-to-058757
agm: The statement that two (or more) things in thermal contact are at the same temperature is a statement on thermal equilibrium. Conversely, if they are not at the same temperature, then they not in equilibrium and there will be a net heat flow — tending towards a new equilibrium, unless additional heat Q or work W is added or extracted. If you cannot define a temperature difference, then we wouldn’t have the laws of thermodynamics as they are defined now.
I’m not sure we’re arguing here. (grin)
Dr. Phil
I think this can be summed up quite neatly in visual form.