A Small Piece of Advice to Hopeful “Big Idea” Participants

It is:

Query first, and don’t write up a Big Idea piece until/unless you have a confirmed date from me. Why? Because there are going to be times when I say “sorry, no space,” and you’ll have written that essay for nothing. And I’d hate for you to waste your time like that.

So, please query first. Thanks.

Comments

  1. Christopher Turkel says:

    I had a big idea while eating Cheerios…can I query you?

  2. Ben says:

    It strikes me, though I am not an author, that writing an essay intended for the Big Idea that is never to be might not be a TOTAL waste of time. If nothing else, it would help organize and focus thoughts about what makes your book unique, which might be useful in other marketing venues.

    Just, you know, in case anyone already wrote theirs before querying. Now you don’t have to feel too bad.

  3. Kyle Maxwell says:

    Agreed with Ben @2. The essay itself still might have a place in other venues besides just Big Idea at Whatever. :)

  4. I actually just posted that on my blog, Ben, that every author should write a Big Idea piece, first for their own benefit, secondly to market the book.

  5. John Scalzi says:

    Ben, Kyle:

    In most cases, non-fiction outlets want to be queried rather than be presented with an article which may or may not fit the needs of the venue. So, no, actually, it wouldn’t necessarily be useful at all to write it out.

    Betsy, likewise while I think it’s useful for authors to outline what about their book makes it special for the purpose of pitching it to venues, writing out a very specific type of article isn’t necessarily useful.

    Writers are busy enough; having them write full articles of a very specific type is a lot of extra work, for a benefit that could be realized more compactly.

  6. eviljwinter says:

    I have this novel idea about a struggling writer who works as an IT drone at an insurance company and is going to college in his middle age. His wife is a hot blonde.

    OK, that last part is based on me.

    Do I need to wait until iUniverse says my check cleared before I can do The Big Idea?

  7. MikeB says:

    Most of my ideas right now are somewhat small. Like realising I don’t know for how long I managed to miss the Lucious Johnson quote/snippet.

  8. John Scalzi says:

    I only recently made it visible again, is probably why.

  9. mensley says:

    I only recently made it visible again, is probably why.

    Aw, shucks. I felt like such an insider hitting ctrl-a every so often to see what the invisible quote was.

  10. adelheid says:

    mensley @9 I just highlighted the top part of the page. I guess I wasn’t in the club.

  11. Estara says:

    Will their be a grace period for the authors in question, or was I too stupid to realize you had this limitation on the Big Idea submission post from the start?

    … I wouldn’t be surprised if I hadn’t read closely enough myself.

This is the place where you leave the things you think

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s