123 Comments on “A Really Important Request”

1. It would be gross.

   Deliciously, deliciously gross.

2. Wait, you shouldn’t? This is foreign to me.

3. Because your breath would smell horrible forever. Also if you do that, you’re just a pair of bib over-alls away from being a total hill billy.

4. CHUG IT!
   CHUG IT!
   CHUG IT!

   Because if you do not your a wuss.

5. Because the sugar will cause a spike and crash in your blood sugar, leaving you weeping and shaking, which will upset both Athena and Ghlaghghee, even if you care nothing for yourself.

   Because the onslaught of saline and sugar may cause your stomach to rebel, leading to you chanting the holy name of Ralph at His porcelain altar.

   Because it would set a poor example for…oh wait, you don’t care about that! :-)

6. Heh. Make sure you have a good sightline to the toilet, ’cause you are gonna need it. I would lay good money on spew from both ends.

7. If you do, please don’t take a photo diary chronicling it. Think of the children…

8. Even though they’re sweet pickles I’m sure they’re high in sodium. If you’re aiming to mummify your body for posterity go for it. If you’re looking to live longer and write more excellent books I plead that you just pour the sweet pickle juice down the drain

9. Because then everyone will want some.

10. Because you really should capture this on video to post, both the chugging and subsequent physiological reactions, and that would be kind of a bother.

11. Because the sheer disgustingness (It is too a word!) of the act will cause a rift in the time-space continuum, causing you to be replaced by your evil, goateed double. Said double will immediately shave, endorse McCain/Palin, call for SFnal YA to be banned from local libraries, and acknowledge that Pluto was never really a planet.

    Okay, the last part would be an improvement, but still…

12. It’s impossible to prove a negative, John.

    That being said, go for it.

13. Do you have enough sweet pickle juice for everyone? If not, you can’t have any either. It would be rude.

14. When you figure out the answer to your half of the quesiton, can you explain to me why you *should* drink the pickle juice?

15. Two words: pickle breath.

16. Because it makes me sick just to think of it. Gah.

17. Because sweet pickles are an abomination onto the lord.

    Seriously, be a man: chug a jar of full-sour kosher pickle juice. It’ll be awesome!

18. You will:

    1. Turn green.
    2. Have a spike in your blood pressure so high from the salt content that a small blood vessel in your brain will burst, forever causing you to mix up your right and your left and recite the lyrics from Elton John’s “Rocketman” a la William Shatner.
    3. Never be able to eat sweet pickles again.
    4. Kill a fairy, because any time anyone chugs a container of sweet pickle juice, a fairy dies. I *thought* you knew that. :(
    6. Exacerbate the current pickle juice shortage and drive prices of pickle juice futures well above the current high market level of $140.00 a barrel.
    7. The resultant sugar crash will leave you comatose on the couch, watching bad daytime tv.
    8. 8. I forget what 8 was for and
    9. You will forget to use the number 5.
    10. Crack cocaine. I am sure its related somehow, so just say no.

19. You may kill a tapeworm or three.

20. Does your wife like sweet pickles? If not drinking it could make you unkissable for some time.

    the belches aren’t nearly as sweet coming up as going down.

21. Two words.

    Homeless Pickels

22. Because I will totally yack.

23. I double-dog dare you!

24. Are you drinking it before or after the glass of milk?

25. Your wife will think you’re strange.

26. I see no reason not to. Enjoy

27. Why would you want to?

28. Because the webcam isn’t plugged in.

29. The only excuse for drinking pickle juice is that you just ran a marathon. And you don’t want to start running marathons, do you?

30. Dill pickle juice is better.

    Really.

31. Unless you like having working kidneys, I don’t see why not.

32. Because you should tape it to your cat.

33. It’ll give you a bellyache.

    I know. :P

34. Mmmm … delicious pickle juice-y goodness. I myself have given up resisting its siren call.

35. Your pee will turn green.

    It may be permanent.

36. Because I’ll throw up. I might anyway. Thanks ever so much.

37. Because you haven’t got the live video feed set up yet. Once that’s taken care of, knock yourself out.

38. Asking such a question is tantamount to standing on a high-rise ledge and expecting this particular crowd not to start shouting “Jump! Jump! Jump!” and selling “Die, Scalzi, Die!” T-shirts and starting a betting pool (ODDS: Splatter [3:1], Bounce [4:1], Chicken out [1:1], Scream like a girl all the way down [sucker bet, no odds given]).

    So, you know, Chug! Chug! Chug! – but let me get a couple of T-shirts silk screened up first…

39. If you have only a few sips now, it will last longer.

40. Drinking it will help you beat the Dallas Cowboys

41. A friend of mine once did that with the brine from a jar of olives and the following dehydration headache, nausea and shakes made her feel as though death would be a sweet, sweet mercy.

    Yeah, she never did that again.

    On the bright side, a spoonful or two of sweet pickle juice is an excellent secret ingredient in deviled eggs.

42. You shouldn’t drink it because it’s better as popsicles.

43. You should tape it to the cat instead.

44. Because somewhere there’s a pregnant woman who wants it more?

    Because it’s too strong drunk straight. You should slice up a cucumber and drop the slices in there. In an hour or two you eat them.

45. Because sweet pickles are nasty!

46. 1.) Because you won’t be able to go swimming for at least an hour afterwards.

    2.) Because your face will be stuck like that.

    3.) Because it’s specifically forbidden to do so in the Book of Deuteronomy.

    4.) Because I said so!

47. Because sweet pickle juice goes so much better with Sunday morning bacon.

48. Are you mad? Don’t you know there is a world shortage of sweet pickle juice and you are set to consume an entire JAR? That pickle juice could supply a family in Komenos for a month, and here you are, threatening to DRINK it all? I cannot believe the utter selfishness! Pickle juice is a valuable commodity and sweet… Have you no shame? Think of all the Komenosians who will shiver in the darkness for lack of pickle juice, do they not MOVE you? Have you no compassion for the pickle juice deprived of the world?

    If you drink that pickle juice, it will be a crime against humanity. Just say no, don’t do it, think of the children! Your pickle juice will keep them supplied until relief can be organized, for the sake of FSM, just think about it!

49. Eeeeew.

50. No Drink, add hardboiled eggs, beet juice and apple cider vinegar for delicious snacks all winter long.

51. John,
    In your last post you were apologising for not getting through your eamil, now you want to drink a container of something that will probably have you stuck in the bathroom the rest of the day, if not the weekend?

    But hey man, it’s your life.

    eric @#25, if John’s wife doesn’t know he’s strange, she hasn’t been paying attention.

    Kevin

52. Let’s see, it’s been about an hour since you posted, and considering that the phrasing of your request made it seem as though your mouth was watering uncontrollably at the thought of tasting that wondrous juice, I’d wager you already drank it.

    Or tried, anyway…

53. A) Eww. 2) Icky. iii) Won’t somebody think of the pickles?!

54. Because you’re clearly only asking to get attention.

55. You’ll put your eye out.

56. You only THINK it’s sweet pickle juice.

57. I agree with Mitchelle.

    Dill pickle juice is just so much better. Especially if it is spicy.

    Also if you drink it all now, you won’t have any left for later.

58. Go ahead but remember:

    if you drink sweet pickle juice then the terrorists have won.

59. Well, I suppose the optimal question is, “do you like sweet pickle juice?”

    If the answer is no, you don’t particularly like it, then you shouldn’t consume it. (Life is too short to eat things we hate!) But if you do like sweet pickle juice, then I see no reason why you shouldn’t.

    -kat

60. Because you have work to do, and vomiting pickle juice — as rich a field for comic blog fodder as that might be — doesn’t pay the bills.

61. You would be sooo nauseous after.
    So I guess it all depends what you plan for the rest of the day.

62. I want to see a video of this. The aftermath may become as famous as bacon taped to a cat.

63. Eh. Sweet pickle juice? Nah.

    Dill pickle juice – hell yeah! Chug that bitch.

    I do that all the damn time along with eating the salt at the bottom of a bag of pretzels.

64. Vinegar can increase the body’s absorption of important minerals from the foods we eat. Of course, if you chug the stuff, this benefit will be negated when your stomach contents spill forth. I say control the urge and take the lady’s advice and make deviled eggs…with bacon bits.

65. MMMM pickle juice. There is no reason to avoid it. ;-)

66. Simple reason, as learned by my kid sister back in 8th grade: If you do, in about two hours you’re gonna be SO thirsty….

    (They had hamburgers at lunch that day, and the table got into a pickle-eating contest. Being the academy, we ate family-style with a faculty member as head of each table. The music teacher told them they were gonna be thirsty… “Oh, no, we won’t.”

    About mid-way through glee club the *entire* alto row had to flee for the fountain…. much to the “I-told-you-so” amusement of the music teacher. :)

67. Hey, why don’t you just start your own version of “John, Don’t Eat It!”

    This would be good.

68. Because that’s not what the expression “getting pickled” means.

69. Because you learned your lesson the hard way that time you and Soup went out to fish for crappies?

70. Here’s why not:

    Think of the withering glance Krissy will give you if you catches you.

    On the other hand, I’ve seen sauerkraut juice canned for beveragy consumption, so go for it.

71. Pickled beet juice is better.

    AND it turns your urine purple!

72. “#
    # BC Woodson 12 Sep 2008 at 12:18 pm

    Because your breath would smell horrible forever. Also if you do that, you’re just a pair of bib over-alls away from being a total hill billy.”

    And what is wrong with that? I come from a long line of hill folk and own several pairs of overalls. Besides, everyone knows sweet pickle juice is for city folk in the flatlands. Real hillbillies chug dill pickle juice. Mixed with ‘shine. Shaken, not stirred.

73. Because there are starving children in third world countries that have yet to be saved by Angelina Jolie that need that pickle juice more than you do!

74. Because the results will be the future horror glimpsed by Obama:

    http://www.theonion.com/content/news_briefs/obama_suddenly_panicked?utm_source=onion_rss_daily

75. Because pickle juice consumption brings you that much closer to partaking in tentacle porn. Don’t you want after-school specials?

76. Watch. I meant watch after-school specials. *Puts down pickle juice bong*

77. Do not try to drink the pickle-juice; that’s impossible. Instead, only strive to realize the truth: there is no pickle-juice.

78. I’m with the numerous others who’ve mentioned dill’s superiority in this matter.

79. Why bother when you can find a good jar of pepperoncini and, after eating them, chug that liquid? Sweet pickles are for eating, but the brine on hot pickles is for drinking!

80. Seriously. For just a few seconds there, this post made me hate Ohio. The feeling has passed. Just. Too. Visceral.

81. You’re a grown man. Make up your own damn’ mind about drinking the pickle juice.

82. you should NOT drink it simply because after telling people that it was a possibility they would want you to and by NOT doing it you would spite all these people and trick them into thinking you would it would be truly devilish.

83. Because it’s sweet pickles and sweet pickles are naaaaaaasssstttttyyyyyyyyy.

84. Mass amounts of pickle-ing solution?

    PermaPucker.

    Both ends.

85. Gack.
    Is this the first hint we have of your next opus, “Pregnant Male Author: A Memoir?”

    Had to ask,
    Lauretta

86. Because there is no chocolate in it?

87. Because what goes in, must come out.

88. Because that would be a waste. You should pour it in a bong and use it to sweeten the flavor of clove cigarette smoke.

    If you must drink it, add a bunch of peach schnapps first. Peach schnapps will improve the flavor of any liquid.

89. That could not possibly end well.

90. Because, John. Just because.

    Seriously, if all your friends drank pickle juice, would you drink it too? You were raised better than that.

91. ok, by current count we’ve got 56 reasons why you shouldn’t, with strong representation from the “that’s nasty” and “drink something else” camps.

    14 folks urging you on. mostly of the “why not?” persuasion. See above 56 reasons.

    9 people simply want you to do something for their amusement, involving pictures of your pain and/or cats

    and 8 folks asked a question or didn’t express an opinion

    Your public has spoken. You shouldn’t drink it.

    Why do I agree with the majority here?

    Because if you go with the folks who want to see the aftermath, it has a pretty good chance of catching on. Then you will receive pickle themed gifts in addition to the bacon. Or, if you are particularly unlucky, pickled bacon.

92. Because it’s better with vodka?

93. WAIT—until someone else is there to take before & after pictures.

    Of you, not the jar.

94. Because it’s nasty. Like, duh.

95. Before diabetes ended my sweet pickle adventures I would always save the pickle juice. A little bit added nice flavours to stews and sauces.

    MMM!!!

    If you drink the pickle juice, you can’t do that.

    Cheers
    Andrew

96. Well, did you or didn’t you? This is pretty f’ing lame if we never find out.

97. So, didja drink it?

    You’ve kind of left us hanging on how Athena’s bread came out, are you planning on leaving this one unresolved too?

98. Because the salt is bad for your blood pressure, and the vinegar and sugar are bad for your teeth?

99. Because you are actually sleep-walking, and the jar of mayonaise and cigarette butts would make a better snack.

100. Um…
     *whispers* That’s not pickle juice.

101. Two words: Pickled colon.

102. Because it will kill you…well maybe not, but why take the chance?

103. Perhaps you should add some to Athena’s next attempt at bread, for a second entry in the Scalzi Recipe book. The first, of course, is schadenfreude pie.

104. John, I can’t answer your question, but I need to know whether you drank it, ASAP. Call, email, IM, just let me know, ‘K?

     signed, a turkey in suspense

105. Because then the pickles will have nowhere to live.

106. I did the fraternity thing for a while when I was in Riverside. Didn’t like it much. Lots of interesting memories, though, including one memorable night when, half-drunk, a fraternity brother drank an entire jar’s worth of pickle juice.

     His… gastronomical processes… were decidedly Unpleasant for the next couple of days.

107. Because then there won’t be any left for me.

     … Wait, you said sweet pickle juice. Uh, in that case, drink up! Dill pickle juice is my beverage of choice.

108. I’m guessing with a time lag like that, he’s in a pickle juice coma.

109. Two words: Natural laxative.

110. Because I work at the pickle juice bottling factory, and I spat in that jar.

111. Don’t, are you TRYING to self-terminate?

112. diarrhea

113. Because you should conjure up a couple/a few (depending on jar size) hard boiled eggs and let them sit in the juice overnight. Then tomorrow at snack time — oh boy! Pickled eggs! (I have recently done this; I have also drunk some of that juice — approx. 5 oz. — and I tell you that I was none-the-worse for indulging.)

114. Sweet pickles are nasty. Do it with those hot pepper rings that some people put in sandwiches. Now *that*’s an experience.

     Of course, if your wife catches you, she might think you’re pregnant.

115. You must drink the pickle juice to prepare your body for the afterlife, O Great Pharaoh!

116. It’s too late, isn’t it? The deed has either been done or it hasn’t. Did you or didn’t you? My money’s on a single swig. Too much of a good thing is too much of a good thing.

117. Because it isn’t as tasty as bacon-covered cat? Those pictures you’re showing of Ghlag don’t fool anybody.

118. Salutations, Mr. Scalzi, and ye other gentlefolken,

     OTOH, pickle juice is often in cooking soups, stews, baked beans, deviled eggs, and ‘homemade pickled’ cucumbers and boiled eggs.

     OTOH, it has been used as a ‘substitute Gatorade’ by athletic teams in hot humid weather – depending on the weather in Dallas on Monday, the ESPN announcers may discuss that – or google “pickle juice” and “Philadelphia Eagles” for more info.

     And how did Athena’s breadmaking turn out ? The world wonders.

     Yours, John Desmond

     PS – GO IGGLES !

119. Because the container in question is a 55 gallon drum and you have no idea where it’s been.

120. I may be too late, but it could give you nightmares. For weeks possibly.

121. Because Krissy will kill you if she gets home and there’s none left for her.

122. Keeps ya from catchin’ cold!

123. Drink the juice, Shelby…