Worth the Read
Posted on December 23, 2008 Posted by John Scalzi 39 Comments
Sports Illustrated’s cover story on what’s happened to the dogs that were part of Michael Vick’s dog fighting kennel. It turns out the large majority of them are living and some are even thriving, which is a miracle when you remember that even PETA thought they needed to be put down. But it should also go without saying that bringing these dogs back from the hell Vick put them in hasn’t been an easy task, which is why, as we say here in the Internet biz, you want to read the whole thing. Speaking as a dog owner, I’m glad these dogs are free and Vick’s in a cage. It’s justice.
Isn’t Vick scheduled to get out soon? It seems a little soon, but his career is shot and after legal fees, I can’t imagine he has a whole lot of money left.
Got to see (from a distance) the setup for the 22 dogs Best Friends got when I volunteered there in June. Great stuff these folks do.
One of the things that interested me about this article was this bit, in the section detailing the bad p.r. or pit bulls:
“Some contend that this hysteria reached its apex with a 1987 Sports Illustrated cover that featured a snarling pit bull below the headline beware of this dog. Despite the more balanced article inside, which was occasioned by a series of attacks by pit bulls, the cover cemented the dogs’ badass cred, and as rappers affected the gangster ethos, pit bulls became cool.”
It’s hard not to see SI as attempting to atone for a past error, with this cover–and good for SI, if so.
oh goodness. Heart warming and heart breaking all at once. Little sweet ones. Why does it ever make sense to be so cruel to them.
Thank you so much for linking this. I needed something to bolster my faith in humanity. And, of course, I’m so glad the dogs are doing well. They deserve it.
Dogs are my favorite people.
I can’t believe anyone would make them fight… it kind of makes me sick.
I’m glad that 47 of the dogs could be saved, but 4 dead dogs is still 4 too many. :-(
I’m gonna go snuggle my puppy now.
If the episode of “Dog Town” about Best Friends rehabilitating several of the Vicks dogs ever turns up again on NatGeo, I highly recommend it, too.
That bastard should never be allowed out. Ever.
Ron@7: As it happens, the episode is on this coming Sunday, the 28th, at 9 pm. Here’s a link to the episode guide page. There is a marathon of other Dogtown episodes on tomorrow (Christmas Eve) starting at 2 pm.
Best Friends’ John Garcia and the toothless female Georgia were on Ellen DeGeneres’ show last week. Here’s the clip.
What’s interesting to me is that at volunteer orientation at the Humane Society here in hippie Ann Arbor (which, btw, is not actually affiliated with the American Humane Society, or at least they don’t get any money from them), I was told that dogs rescued from fighting rings are not impossible to rehabilitate. Far from it. The quote was something like, “dogs trained to fight adore humans, but they do want to kill other dogs…”
Actually, PETA may crow about how much they support animal rights; but when it comes down to it their “solution” is almost always to put the dogs down.
Google PETA, and “euthanasia” or “no kill shelter”, the results might be surprising to you… or not, if you’re actually aware of how hypocritical and downright fraudulent an organization PETA is.
Note, I don’t necessarily apply this to PETA members or supporters; who are mostly just trying to good things for animals; but most of them don’t know what PETA really is, or does.
Similarly, the rather inappropriately named “humane society of the united states” is anything but. They advocate and fund mass euthanasia for animals. In fact, a condition of funding for animal “rescue” programs supported by the HSUSA is a 7 day kill policy.
The HSUSA are NOT, nor are they in any way affiliated with the American Humane Society, or the American Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals; each of which has a more than 100 year track record of good work preventing cruelty to animals, and promoting animal rescue.
The HSUSA is chiefly a political action organization dedicated to ending hunting, and the industrial production of animal products and meat. They are strongly affiliated with domestic terrorist groups like Earth First, ELF and ALF.
Unfortunately, the ASPCA gives money to PETA. Which is why they get none of ours.
Sorry to be OT.
It’s quite amazing how cute pit bulls can be, for something that has the basic anatomy of a land shark.
And I’m back, having read the article. Some friends of mine were members of BAD RAP and fostered, eventually adopting, a pit bull mix. She is quite possibly my favorite dog ever–and I don’t really like dogs.
I’m glad to see that these dogs were for the most part rescued and it’s nice to see the media actually realizing that pits are not inherently bad dogs. Now if only someone could convince governments of that…
Ha. PETA are such losers and this only confirms it. It’s nice to see a magazine with such a large readership pointing out that these dogs are AMAZING with people, and that you ban the DEED, not the BREED.
I think it’s interesting the PETA is getting more hatin’ in this thread so far than Michael Vick.
I also don’t particularly think this is the thread for a PETA pile on.
Thank you for the link, sir. At this time of year, we honor the birth of a Teacher who taught love and peace, and I can’t think of a better story for the season.
Please pass on some skritchies to your own furries.
One last PeTA bash: “which is a miracle when you remember that even PETA thought they needed to be put down” also applies to burlap sacks full of kittens. :(
Mr. Scalzi, I believe you hold undue influence over me. I just voluntarily read a Sports Illustrated story for the first time ever. And enjoyed it. Fie on you and your evil ways!
I’m glad that Vick’s dogs got a well deserved second chance.
I think any condition of Vick’s release ought to involve him, sidewalks, and a pooper scooper. For about 5 years.
PETA — Isn’t that People Eating Tasty Animals?
Without in ANY way criticizing the marvelous work that BAD RAP and the other groups in this story did saving these dogs – I wish all the abused or abandoned animals in our shelters got so much help.
I live in a ridiculously wealthy part of the country and our local animal shelter is well-funded. We get animals sent here from all over the state, because the shelter can keep animals for a long time and they are adopted out pretty quickly. The shelter folks tell me that they have a huge influx of pets, particularly dogs, because people are losing their homes and being shipped off to Iraq and have nobody to care for their animals.
I hate getting misty-eyed at my desk at work.
I have a rescue dog: A german sheppard/lab. She might have more in her–some have suggested Pit bull. When our trainer worked with her on some “assertiveness” issues, I told her I was worried about the pit bull angle and the trainer said: “So what? Pit bulls are loveable dogs. They’re also smart enough to be trained to be killers. Or lovers. It’s not an instinct, it’s intelligence. And, by the way, ANY dog can be violent and bite. ANY DOG.”
My husband’s best friend had a pit bull and she was the most loving dog, wonderful with adults, other pets, and kids alike. And smaaaart.
ANY dog can be violent and bite. ANY DOG.
Quite true, but that’s not really the valid objection to Pit Bulls. The problem is, they were bred for fighting – they have unbelievable muscular and especially cranial structure. If you try to make a Pit Bull let go of your kid’s arm by hitting it in the head with a hammer, it’s just gonna bounce off. Pit Bull are essentially biological weapons.
I think the best solution is for the breed to be allowed to die out. If dog people want a pit bull-like creature (looks & personality; they’re apparently pretty great when they’re not trying to kill you), they should have to recreate the breed, like was done with Siamese Cats years ago. I can’t say I’m a big fan of having a pet that has the capability of killing me, or mauling the face off a neighbor kid.
I’m at the top of the food chain, and I intend to stay there.
@ Tumbleweed, what exactly is this breed called a pit-bull that you refer to, as far as I am aware the pit-bull/pit-bull type designation has been found to cover between 20 to 35 different breeds.
Taking this fact into account (and manipulating statistics for my own purposes) I could argue that this therfore means that the 118 deaths in the USA (over 20 years!) attributed to pit bull types in the much quoted CDC study should be reduced to between 4 and 6 deaths over 20 years for each of those breeds the type covers.
This means that it can be said that the Mastiff, Boxer, Collie, Chow Chow, Doberman, Saint Bernard, Great Dane, Labrador Retriever, Akita, Sled-type, Pit bull-type, Rottweiler, German Shepherd Dog, Husky-type, Malamute, Wolf-dog hybrid and Mixed-breed are all as, or more, dangerous than any of the individual pit-bull breeds.
In fact there are probably more people killed by their trousers each year in the USA than are killed by the pit-bull type.
According to the FBI Black people commit over 50% of murders in the USA but according to the US Census Bureau only make up around 10% of the population, is it your suggestion that the best solution is for the black race to be allowed to die out? Or would your suggestion be that through improving living conditions, fairer distribution of resources, combating discrimination and education people try to change that situation
I have to admit to a potential conflict of interest in that my dog (a jack russell / staffordshire bull terrier) would fall under the pit-bull type umbrella, in fact I live in North-Staffordshire the home of the Staffie.
My dog is the most loving little animal (though not when it comes to squirrels rats and rabbits), she is incredibly people orientated but I trust her no more than I would any other dog because when it comes down to it they are a WOLF one of the more efficient killing machines out there. This is something that the parents of babies killed by Yorkshire terriers or chihuahuas wish they had remembered.
Try getting to know the dogs before you decide that genocide is the only option.
Oh before I forget, thank-you John for posting the link to the Sports Illustrated article.
If you don’t want a pet that has the capability of killing you, you shouldn’t have any dog. Even chihuahua could (and have) ‘mauled the face off’ of children.
Come to think of it, most pets are dangerous in some way. If you’re that worried about the small chance that a medium-sized terrier is going to bite you, I’m hoping you never own a cat. Much greater risk of injury.
I personally couldn’t be happier with the story of the Vick dogs. Well, the only thing that would make me happier is if it really did help dispel some of the ignorance and breed-hatin’ that goes on out there.
Tumbleweed, you’re not at the top of the food chain. Unless you’re also proposing that we wipe out wolves, lions, hyenas and any other predator you can’t fend off with a carpenter’s hammer?
I don’t have any clue what you mean by ‘recreating the breed’ wrt Siamese cats. Are you thinking of Russian Blues?
Hi! First off, thank you for the article – I had thought that Best Friends had taken all the dogs, and none were going to be allowed to be adopted out.
But I always have mixed feelings on cases like this, because it becomes a number issue. For the amount of time and money spent to find these dogs a permanent home, how many easily adoptable dogs with great social skills died in a shelter waiting for a home?
Also, Speaking of dogs and aggression, The Chihuahua is usually at the top of the list for biting because they tend to be high strung and very often poorly socialized, due to the popularity plus backyard breeding. Labs are also big on biting due to poor socialization, no training, and backyard breeders. All dog and child/stranger interactions should be carefully monitored, in almost every case of a dog bite, especially in children, you find that the dog and child were not supervised. All it takes is a stepped on tail, or pulled ear, for a dog to automatically bite – the dog almost always regrets his action.
A lot of people seem to complain that the resources that saved these dogs could have been better spent elsewhere. This is not quite accurate; the court ordered Vick to pay for all of this. The money is coming from the evildoer, and no shelter is getting less due to these programs. As such, resources aren’t an issue. Besides, shouldn’t the volunteers handling these dogs be the ones to choose how to use their own time?
Anyway, great story, thanks for the link. Also, the only breed of dog that I have personally found to be almost always vicious is the Chihuahua. For all dogs, though, people make the difference.
If you substituted baby/kid instead of puppy/dog, this story would have gotten a lot fewer replies and compassion. Yes, I know this a story about dogs, but I just wanted to throw this out as food for thought. And I am glad that most of the dogs are doing better. Thanks!
If you substituted “baby” for “dog,” it wouldn’t make any damn sense, since no one starts a baby-fighting gambling ring.
Let’s not stretch ourselves to make a point that doesn’t need to made, okay?
Fair enough. Sorry.
John, what are you talking about? They’re called “Pre-Schools”. (Ok, ok, I’m done being inappropriate.)
Anyway, I just got back from vacation, and am catching up on stuff, so I only just saw the article. Thanks for posting it. I’m glad to hear those dogs are in loving homes.
The description of Jasmine at the beginning of the article was haunting. I am certain that dog was beaten, repeatedly. A friend of mine adopted an abused greyhound (another breed commonly in need of rescuing). Zulu only let me pet her once in the eight or so years I knew her. Jasmine’s behavior is a dead ringer for Zulu’s. Zulu would trust other people–my friend, her rescuer–but not me: Zulu was beaten by a guy with facial hair, and I usually walk around bearded.
It is horrible, and I am glad Vicks went to jail and had his life destroyed. He got what he deserved. Dogs feel pain, and they can be emotionally scarred just like people. Zulu was a hard dog to be around, because the best I could do for her was stay out of her way and leave her in peace.
I’m interested in puchacing the Dec.23,2008 copy with Micheal Vic k story with the PitBull; How would I find one? Thank you
This isn’t Sports Illustrated. You’ll have to ask them.
[deleted for stupidity — JS]