50 Comments on “Scam Attempt Warning for SF/F Writers”

1. Yeah, it’s turned up on a couple mailing lists I subscribe to, there to be roundly mocked.

2. I stumbled about “We are officially writing to invite you and confirm your booking as our guest Speaker.” Why should someone confirm something he has never spoken about with you before.

   If this is a workable scam, i now have a way to get my favorite writers to Germany ;-).

3. Karen Healey:

   Yup. As noted I suspect most SF/F folks will see it for what it is, and very quickly. Because they’re not dumb. But it doesn’t hurt to raise the alarm.

4. UK phone numbers starting with 7 are usually, if not always reserved for mobile phones. Living about 5m from Bexley College, I would say that I’d try to attend such an event should it turn out to be genuine (hah).

5. John:

   No, it doesn’t hurt at all. A public service, in fact.

6. Mike Woodhouse said: “UK phone numbers starting with 7 are usually, if not always reserved for mobile phones.”

   True for 71, 72, …79, but the exception is the 70 range, which is for redirection numbers, not mobiles.

7. What kind of UK academic signs off with “Stay Blessed”?

   SHEESH.

8. What sort of UK acadaemic institution would give it’s address as:
   “Upper Holly Hill Road Belvedere, Kent
   London, United Kingdom”
   Hint: Kent is a county, London is a city (which isn’t in Kent… ;) )

9. Reblogged this on The Fog of Ward and commented:
   A scam warning from Scalzi. This one seems to be targeting SF/F writers, but I imagine similar schemes exist for other genres, as well. I don’t always go to conventions, but when I do they’re legit cons run by good folks. Stay wary, my friends.

10. Even very smart people can be taken in by scams that play on their hopes and ego. These sorts of scams need to be pointed out.

    Speaking of public awareness, this phishing scam test is a bit outdated but still a useful teaching tool: http://www.sonicwall.com/furl/phishing/

11. Actually Kaal, I’m minutes from Bexley. My address is Erith, Kent however I live in the London Borough of Bexley and zone 4 of the London transport network. Local addresses are weirdly complex. Clearly a scam overall though.

12. @Kaal: what Max said. London-the-postal-district is a lot smaller than Greater London-the city (although still substantially larger than the actual City of London). As such, the correct postal addess for some of the more suburban districts lies in one of the adjacent counties (or occasionally in Middlesex, which otherwise doesnt exist any more).

13. Pretty obvious and stupid scam, too. Protip: If you want to phish writers, at least get your grammar right. Random Capitalization is a bad Idea, as well.

14. SEEMS LEGIT.

15. I received one of these emails, and was most amused by it. Didn’t think to raise the alarm, so I’m glad you did. But might I suggest as you’re president of SFWA, and SFWA has a relationship with AboutSF, that an email go out to SFWA members?

16. I’ve already alerted both AboutSF and Writer Beware, of course.

17. I’m embarrassed to say that if this had come in from a non-English speaking venue, I would have excused all the obvious red-flags as –oh, they are translating from Russian, Polish, Turkish, whatever language I am unfamiliar with– and I would have responded before I realized it was a scam. Thanks for the heads up.

18. I got some reports of this exact scam last July–only difference is it was Kings College in London and the signer was “Prof. Harry Stewart.” I tried to persuade the people who contacted me to take it a little further–at least an email response–but no one was willing. So who knows what the actual scam is. I suspect it involves travel fees.

19. Could anyone who has received one of these emails–either now or in the past–forward it to me? beware [at] sfwa.org. Thanks.

20. @Kaal I grew up in London, but went to school in an Essex postal area, but in a London Borough (but my home used to be a villiage in Essex, but is now part of London).
    I now live in a London borough, insde the Mayor of London’s domain, but my address is Middlesex (which doesn’t exist outside of addresses, a cricket club and strange uses like giving your birth county when matriculating at some older universities which for such ritual purposes still use 16th Century counties…)
    Such strange things happen when cities evolve over many centuries and absorb ancient villiages and towns (where I currently live has been inhabited for longer than London itself!)

21. Trivial variations of this are all over the net, and has been around since at least 2010. Here’s someone who replied to a “Professor Dave Christopher” to see what happened next:

    http://techland.time.com/2010/10/25/adventures-in-social-engineering-why-i-turned-down-10k-and-an-honorary-degree/

22. Yup. The lack of specifics about me or my work, combined with the odd willingness to fly a writer not even published in the UK overseas, had me pretty sure this was a scam. But was nice to be able to quickly confirm the fact, just the same, so thanks.

23. Oh, Googling for “we say it’s up to standard” with the quotes gives “about 52,300 results,” with the earliest from 2009 or so. The hits include an article by a TED speaker who was successfully scammed for about $1,000 in “work permit” costs… (why, of course the UK border agency uses anonymous Western Union transfers to collect fees).

24. Well done for the heads-up. Our eyebrows are still raised by the ‘University of Glastonbury’, which appeared across S E Asian websites a year or so ago – the address is actually a car park, and the shiny building which accompanied enrolment info was in fact part of the real Uni of De Montfort, about 200 miles to the north. Enterprising scam, though, and Bexley would appear to be a minor variant of that.(Liz W)

25. Greetings to you with joy and celebration,

    it is with infinite sadness that I sit to this letter as I watch the dissolution of every one to my country, for I am Oil Minister, as my secretary cruelly betrayed me and we are seeing the fruit of said time. I have four million dollars in copies of excellent literature, notably John Scalzi’s Redshirts, that I need to transport to safety before they are taken to rebels.

    I entreat your help for I am affirmed that you are trustworthy, as one of character and noble soul, to perform the services under my advise.

    Please to respond to lift my despair to the heavens, and blessings upon your.

26. Sounds like they’d probably accept a reply from just about anybody, because they’re probably not closely keeping track of who they phish. Probably an acceptance email from Prof. Moriarity or Severus Snape would get noticed, but it’d be interesting to find out whether the scammers are actually familiar with English culture or are just picking random details they hope would be convincing to suckers. Randolph Carter has occasionally replied to Nigerian scammers; perhaps he’d be obscure enough.

27. But my chair in creative writing at Nigerian U is still good, right? I sent them a $14,000 deposit last week, but haven’t heard back.

28. Also, an English institution is relatively unlikely to spell honour “honor”. Not impossible, of corse, if an American academic was involved, but still.

29. Bill Stewart at 1:47 pm—I think Kilgore Trout would be the appropriate person to respond.
    On a second re-through, I noticed the American spelling of “honor”. How gracious of the professor to write in the native American tongue!

30. Contact Bexley, set it up and do it for real, funniest way to troll the phishers ever.

31. The funniest thing about the email I just got was the topic I was asked to speak about — “The Mysteries of Life and Death.” As a devout atheist, that would make for a very short talk. I forwarded the letter to Victoria, per request. The typos, weird phrasing, gmail address and the fact that they asked me in the first place (Me? Who am I?) all screamed scam. Thanks for confirming.

    I love writing about science fictional, futuristic scams, but I hope mine come off as clever.

32. Markus: you’re assuming the phishers are actually paying attention to anything other than whether they got a bite at the end of their particular line.

33. From the link supplied by Studer above in which Barton Gellman replies to the scammers:

    “He accepted my terms and sent a contract to engage my services, complete with a request for my banking details so he could wire me an advance. If I had taken the next step,the usual move on his part would have been to say I had to pay a small wire transfer fee, and he’d use the information I supplied to clean me out.”

    Can someone explain how this works? If I send a wire transfer, sure, they get that money, but how can anyone ‘clean me out’? Surely the whole point of a wire transfer is to limit the amount moved to that specified by the sender?

34. @Jonathan Walker: Not sure what Gellman meant by that; it’s either sloppy writing or a misunderstanding. I’m not aware of any standard scamming scenario where the scammers actually get control over your existing accounts (if your bank allows people to withdraw money that easily, look for another bank asap). My understanding is that they usually ask for account numbers etc. early on to help them prioritize — the more willing someone is to give up information, especially when promised money, the more effort he’s worth (the guy that got scammed mentioned 50-60 mails and a half dozen personas before he wired over the first batch of money).

35. It’s likely that this was a variation on the ‘advance fee’ scam wherein, after determining the size of the ‘fee,’ the scammer sends you a check for an amount considerably larger than the original amount and asks you to deposit it and send back the overage– quickly. The check is bogus, but by the time your bank alerts you to this, you will have already sent the money to the scammer and will have to pay the bank back. Western Union is often specified by the scammer as the method you should use to send the money, because WU transfers are virtually anonymous and impossible to trace. For more on this subject, see:

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nigerian_scam

36. Thanks for posting! Alarm bells started going off as I was reading the email from “Arthur Peterson”. Found many of the same things you did, Mr. Scalzi (suspicious email address, vocational college, etc.). A Google search on “Arthur Peterson” “Brexton College” brought me right here. Saved me any more time on this thing. Will reblog in case anyone I’m following has also received the letter. Too bad it’s a scam. A trip to London could have been fun.

37. Topic: ”Mystery of Life and Death”

    Similar lectures are available for free at the local pub.

38. This could actually be one of those “phone scams”. Where calling the number provided re-directs you (,as someone mentions above this is probably a re-direct number,) and that call is charged at $10-50 in some obscure small country. If the scammer keeps 90% of that charge (, with the rest for the phone company,) there’s some money to be made from relatively few calls from people who are curious.

    I don’t remember where I read about those types of phone scams, but I’m pretty sure it was something that was going on with UK numbers.

39. Thanks for posting this! Yes, I too received that ‘invitation. I did forward it to the fine folks at Bexley, so that they are aware someone is using their information etc.

40. So… are you going?

    Where can I get tickets?

    Just jiving :)

41. Where this type of scam gets really sinister is when it targets vulnerable individuals for whom English is a second language.

    My Hungarian flatmate came to me in great excitement because her 17 year old cousin, who had registered with an Au Pair agency, had been offered a job with a lovely ex-pat American family in London.

    It took almost two hours to convince her that a.) the American-born wife of a Professor of Economics would not make elemental grammar errors in her email and that b.) Kensington, while a lovely part of London, does not abound with the type of detached house depicted in the photographs, and definitely does not have an ocean view.

    My concern was not only that, without a native Londoner’s intervention, a teenage girl of limited means was almost ripped off, but that she was on the verge of booking unaccompanied travel by bus to the UK on the strength of the offer.

42. And of course the most obvious red flag? ‘Prof.’ with a period, instead of just ‘Prof’ as any BE speaker would have it.

    Periods after Dr./Mr./Prof. and so on is a ‘deprecated’ usage in British English and has been for a long time. It’s just Dr/Mr/Prof etc.

    Much blessings!

43. Thank you for this. I got an invite too. It sounded suspicious to me and was glad to find this information that you provided to confirm my suspicions.
    Marc Millis

44. The vagueness of the topic (“Mystery of Life and Death”) suggests to me that this scam was built to tug at the ego of all kinds of writers, not just SF ones.

45. Some followup on this scam (which has been running, in various versions, since at least 2009), including what the actual scam is: http://accrispin.blogspot.com/2013/01/alert-uk-speaker-scam-scam-targets.html

46. They got my name off of the ASME (American Society of Mechancial Engineers) speaker’s forum and I received the same e-mail today. Almost identical e-mail but with different “professor’s” name, and I thought it was funny that they would have me speak on “Life and Death”. Funny thing is I am booked to speak on that date but in North Carolina.

47. You’ll find similar scams aimed at ESL teachers, from folks supposedly looking for private tutors for their children. Sometimes the supposed sender is an oil company executive, sometimes a diplomat on a foreign mission.

    The scam is to get the mark to send ever-increasing amounts of money for work permits, licenses, fees, and whatever else the scammer can think of.

48. Our Euro-centric team, before our diaspora over the years, originated from this area and we know Bexley College as a local landmark. Bexley College actually is in ‘Tower Road’ and the college is a tall rectangular block perched on a hillside that literally ‘towers’ over a broad vista of the River Thames curling around Belvedere and Erith. The Holly Hill campus is a temporary affair as the college will be moving.

    As some have commented, the address ‘Kent, London’ is odd. Bexley is what is called a London Borough for local government purposes (including education) but the eastern part of the Borough (and the college) is actually in the county of Kent.

    As you say, Bexley College is a vocational college. A few years ago it appealed to local experts to run evening courses and some of us enquired, but they were not interested in science (or SF).

    Teasing all this apart does make one wonder whether the perpetrators of the hoax have some local knowledge albeit very poor to the point of error, hence the perpetrators may have had some recent/brief connection with the area? Had they gleaned all their information from the internet then they would not have made these mistakes. But adding what they thought was local, factual colour, but which was in reality erroneous, was a mistake.

49. I was hit by this exact same scam. I have over the years gotten some legit invites from odd people at odd institutions and I nearly went for this one. They wanted $1400 for a UK work permit, though, and that broke me from the trance. I have a little info about it at the end of a recent blog post.
    http://www.rudyrucker.com/blog/2013/01/14/charles-strosss-rule-34-and-the-nature-of-mind/

50. As the admin of this site is working, no hesitation very soon it will be well-known, due to its
    feature contents.